Andy Farrell has announced his 42 man training squad for the
world cup, and true to form, has not been afraid to make some hard
choices. The dominant theme is one of loyalty to the players who
have enabled Ireland win a Grand Slam and maintain their place at
the top of the world rankings.
I had expected Munsters outstanding form in recent weeks to have
more of an impact, but in the event some of Munsters outstanding
performers Haley, Daly, Frisch, Loughman, Barron, Archer, Kleyn,
and Hodnett man of the match in the final, have all missed out.
Players like Lowry, Baloucoune, Larmour, Hume, Doak, Timoney,
Penny, and Harry Byrne have also missed out, so it is not only
Munster players who will be feeling disappointed.
I dont think there has ever been so much competition for an
extended squad before. Only four uncapped players Nash, Osborne,
Frawley and Stewart make the squad for their versatility or
potential, with Earls joining Sexton for their last hurrah. There
is thus a nod to the future as well an appreciation of past
achievement: a good mix of experience and potential.
The most extraordinary omission, in my view, is the lack of a
second specialist 7 in the squad as back-up to Van der Flier.
Timoney, Penny, and Hodnett have all missed out. This fuels my
suspicion that Farrell is planning to counter the sheer size of
South African and French packs by employing both Doris and Conan or
even Coombes in the back row, with OMahoney a super-sub covering
all back row positions.
The Springboks have frequently employed Pieter Steph
du Toit, a 6 7 19 stone lock at 7. Doris has covered 7 for
Leinster, and Baird has the pace and athleticism to do so, so
perhaps Farrell feels he can afford to do without a second
specialist 7, even in the extended training squad. Fingers crossed
Van Der Flier doesnt get injured.
So, what are the strengths and weaknesses of the squad when you
measure them against the standards required to be contention to win
the World Cup? Our weaknesses at prop have been mitigated to some
degree by the rise of Bealham and OToole although Furlong has yet
to recover his best form, and depth at loose head remains a
concern. We dont have a monster lock like Will Skelton, but Ryan
and Beirne are in excellent form and players like Baird, Henderson,
or McCarthy could make up for size with athleticism and work
rate.
Farrells investment in Casey has paid off and Murrays form has
improved. Ross Byrne and Crowleys form has allayed fears about
back-up to Sexton, and we have a fine stock of centres. We lack
outstanding pace, elusiveness, or physicality on the wings, but the
work rate of Hansen, Lowe, and OBrien et al seems to mean that this
does not matter all that much. Keenan has become a contender for
best 15 in the world.
In general, our first XV players have continued to improve and
most now have genui...